Search  for anything...

Murder Most Puzzling: The Missing Will 500-Piece Puzzle

  • Based on 370 reviews
Condition: New
Product info up-to-date
$18.95 Why this price?
Holiday Deal · 12% off was $21.59

Buy Now, Pay Later


As low as $4 / mo
  • – 4-month term
  • – No impact on credit
  • – Instant approval decision
  • – Secure and straightforward checkout

Ready to go? Add this product to your cart and select a plan during checkout.

Payment plans are offered through our trusted finance partners Klarna, Affirm, Afterpay, Apple Pay, and PayTomorrow. No-credit-needed leasing options through Acima may also be available at checkout.

Learn more about financing & leasing here.

Selected Option

Free shipping on this product
This item's return window has been extended for the holiday season: FREE refund/replacement until Jan 31, 2026

To qualify for a full refund, items must be returned in their original, unused condition. If an item is returned in a used, damaged, or materially different state, you may be granted a partial refund.

To initiate a return, please visit our Returns Center.

View our full returns policy here.


Availability: In Stock.
Fulfilled by Amazon

Arrives Sunday, Nov 23
Order within 6 hours and 21 minutes
Available payment plans shown during checkout

Color: The Missing Will


Features

  • DISTINCTIVE TWIST ON THE JIGSAW: In this mystery puzzle, the full puzzle image is a secret until you complete the jigsaw, because it contains the crucial clues you need to unravel the mystery. Double the puzzles to solve = double the fun, especially for parties and cozy nights in.
  • PERFECT BLEND FOR MYSTERY AND PUZZLE FANS: For anyone who loves jigsaws and classic mystery stories, this is the ultimate gift. The narrative and illustrations pay homage to beloved creators like Agatha Christie and Edward Gorey.
  • COOL OBJECT: With an elegant box shaped like a book, this makes a special gift and an enviable coffee-table centerpiece.
  • NOSTALGIC APPEAL: This mystery puzzle revamps a popular jigsaw format from the 1990s, inviting puzzlers to rediscover a nostalgic pastime.
  • GORGEOUS ILLUSTRATION: The finished puzzle image is a sumptuous illustration full of rich color, hidden details, and lightly gothic humor.

Description

Murder Most Puzzling: The Missing Will 500-Piece Puzzle

Product Dimensions: 24 x 15.5 x 0.25 inches


Item Weight: 1 pounds


Item model number: 2


Manufacturer recommended age: 9 years and up


Release date: March 1, 2022


Language: English


Manufacturer: Chronicle Books


Frequently asked questions

If you place your order now, the estimated arrival date for this product is: Sunday, Nov 23

Yes, absolutely! You may return this product for a full refund within 30 days of receiving it.

To initiate a return, please visit our Returns Center.

View our full returns policy here.

  • Klarna Financing
  • Affirm Pay in 4
  • Affirm Financing
  • Afterpay Financing
  • PayTomorrow Financing
  • Financing through Apple Pay
Leasing options through Acima may also be available during checkout.

Learn more about financing & leasing here.

Top Amazon Reviews


  • Great Puzzle!
Color: The Missing Will
This puzzle was a lot of fun! I bought it as a replacement for my sis-in-law's puzzle that my kids got some water on. The image is fun and the mystery of it is fantastic! It's colorful, fantastic value, and the quality is good. Anytime a puzzle like this soaks up water, it's going to ruin it, so that was user error, not the fault of the puzzle! It's a nice size and challenge - tons of fun! ... show more
Reviewed in the United States on October 27, 2025 by AOiMhEhE

  • Fun puzzle with a small added mystery
Color: The Clairvoyants' Convention
My husband got this as a gift for me and it was so fun! I love puzzles and mysteries so this was really fun. I loved the small story of what you were trying to solve, and then building the puzzle to see the scene so I could find the culprit based on clues around them.
Reviewed in the United States on October 1, 2025 by Anthony Jimenez

  • Fun puzzle
Color: The Missing Will
This was a really fun puzzle, not too hard. Solving the mystery is pretty challenging. The mystery stands alone because it is part of the book that is sold separately from this puzzle and you really only need the picture that the puzzle makes to solve the mystery so I feel the product description is a little misleading. Also if you have the book you can see the image of the puzzle if you don't want to put it together blind. The image is also in an envelope in the puzzle box. I think given that this is really just a jigsaw puzzle that the product description is a little misleading but it is a really fun and visually appealing puzzle with a challenging brain puzzle within it. ... show more
Reviewed in the United States on December 28, 2023 by Jessica Spivak

  • A great way to spend 3 days at a cabin!
Color: The Missing Will
I enjoyed every moment with this puzzle. I was able to complete it in 3 days. I loved the mystery angle too. I will definitely be ordering more of these puzzles.
Reviewed in the United States on October 25, 2025 by SandraDee

  • Was pleasantly surprised
Color: The Clairvoyants' Convention
Wasn't familiar with the brand and there were no reviews, so took a chance and was pleasantly surprised. Decent quality/thickness cardboard, and they did interlock nicely but not enough to be able to easily move larger sections around. Which is annoying when you don't know the image and will likely have to rearrange sections as their orientation is discovered. Smaller sections move well though. Minimal puzzle dust. Pretty standard piece shapes, but has no issues with pieces fitting together that did not belong, so pretty unique cut. Didn't want to spoil the image, so just included some of the piece shapes and example of how well it interlocks. Image ended up being nice and busy with lots of interesting things to look at, as well as distinctive colors and sections making for a fun puzzle experience. Took me about an hour and a half including sorting. (About normal for a 500 pc puzzle for me.) The story and subsequent mystery were brief but added that extra bit of interaction to the puzzle that makes you stop and really admire all the details in the final puzzle image you may not have noticed while puzzling. I also like that it included a hint before you reveal the full answer rather than an all or nothing kinda thing. The box shape/design is a nice touch and would make a nice gift, but the lid doesn't seem to stay closed super well despite it being slightly magnetic so it snaps close. So storing it vertically would be a risk if it didn't come in a convenient resealable bag. (Which it does, and I always appreciate.) Will probably pick up the other in this series soon. Hope to see more of these in the future! ... show more
Reviewed in the United States on June 24, 2022 by Customer Customer

  • So much fun!
Color: The Missing Will
I received this as a gift and finally was able to take the time to finish it. A great quality puzzle, and it's challenging in that you don't have the normal poster or cover of the box to use as a reference. It's fun to solve the mystery as well. Would recommend as a gift to anyone who loves puzzles (and stories!). ... show more
Reviewed in the United States on August 20, 2025 by Rachel S

  • Good use of quite a few hours.
Color: The Clairvoyants' Convention
I won’t post a picture so as not to ruin it for everyone but the puzzle was missing an end piece. Super frustrating after spending hours putting the puzzle together. It did not take away from trying to solve the mystery though. It was fun and challenging to put the puzzle together with no idea of what the final picture would be. We never peaked! (There is a paper with the picture if needed) I would order another puzzle mystery with the hopes that this one with the missing piece was an anomaly. ... show more
Reviewed in the United States on June 5, 2025 by Kipp Gotfaind

  • Great mystery puzzle
Color: The Missing Will
So much fun to work and dolve
Reviewed in the United States on November 3, 2025 by L. Volz

Can't find a product?

Find it on Amazon first, then paste the link below.