Search  for anything...
DYCE

Pick Your Poison After Dark – Adult Party Game for Friends & Groups | Hilarious “Would You Rather” Card Game | Funny Icebreaker for Game Nights, Parties & Pregames | Great Gift for Adults

Based on 4,384 reviews
Condition: New
Checking for the best price...
$24.95
Holiday Deal was $24.99

Buy Now, Pay Later

As low as $6 / mo
  • – 4-month term
  • – No impact on credit to apply
  • – Instant approval decision
  • – Secure and straightforward checkout

Ready to go? Add this product to your cart and select a plan during checkout.

Payment plans are offered through our trusted finance partners Klarna, Affirm, Afterpay, Zip, Apple Pay, and Google Pay. No-credit-needed leasing options through Acima may also be available at checkout.

Learn more about financing & leasing here.

Free shipping on this product
This item's return window has been extended for the holiday season: FREE refund/replacement until Jan 31, 2027

To qualify for a full refund, items must be returned in their original, unused condition. If an item is returned in a used, damaged, or materially different state, you may be granted a partial refund.

To initiate a return, please visit our Returns Center.

View our full returns policy here.

Availability: In Stock.
Fulfilled by Amazon
Arrives Monday, Nov 16
Order within 13 hours and 34 minutes

Available payment plans shown during checkout

Protect Your Purchase

Easy claims online, fast replacements, no fees

Checking for protection plans...

Recently Viewed

At a glance

Condition
New
Dimensions
7.5 x 4.2 x 3 in
Weight
0.66 g
Color
Multicolor
Material
Cardstock
Age Range Description
15+
Sub Brand
Dyce Games
In the box
CardsBoardRules

Features 4

  • Pick Your Poison is a card game of unfathomable What would you rather do? scenarios
  • Three or more players compete to create the hardest scenario possible by combining two Poison cards
  • Everyone anonymously "Picks their poison" After the reveal, find out who was "right" and who is just as messed up as you thought
  • Combine with the Regular Edition for even more fun!

Description

The Judge expands on them by answering the players’ questions. Players anonymously pick the Poison they would rather do. Tally points and find out which of your friends agree with you and who is just as messed up as you thought.

Specs 35

Age Range Description 15+
Brand Name DYCE
Unit Count 1 Count
Sub Brand Dyce Games
Item Type Name PICK YOUR POISON Card Game: The “What Would You Rather Do?” Game - After Dark Edition
Model Name Pick Your Poison After Dark Edition - "What Would You Rather Do?"
Number of Packs 1
Set Name Pick Your Poison After Dark Edition

Frequently asked questions

The After Dark Edition of Pick Your Poison is designed for adults. It's recommended for players aged 17 and up due to its mature content.

The game is versatile and can be played with 3 to 10+ players. It's perfect for parties, ensuring everyone gets to participate in the fun.

The After Dark Edition is tailored for adults, featuring more mature and provocative scenarios that are not suitable for younger audiences. This version offers a cheekier and more daring set of 'What Would You Rather Do?' scenarios.

The After Dark Edition contains mature content and scenarios that may not be suitable for all audiences. It's important to consider the preferences and sensibilities of all players before choosing this game for your party.

Similar Products

Top Amazon Reviews

🚀 Abunda's Overview

This is our summary and key points to consider based on customer reviews.

The Pick Your Poison Card Game: After Dark Edition shines as a beacon of entertainment for adult game nights, promising a mix of outrageous scenarios, laughter, and bold, often risqué content. Its simple gameplay, coupled with the hilarity of choosing between two extreme "would you rather" scenarios, ensures a lively and memorable experience with friends. The game is lauded for its ability to provoke unexpected discussions, reveal personal quirks, and serve as an excellent ice-breaker at parties, despite the potential for some to find its content over-the-top or not suitable for all audiences.

Pros

  • 🎉 Great for adult game nights, adding excitement and laughter
  • 🃏 Simple to learn, making it accessible for everyone regardless of gaming experience
  • 😂 Provokes hilarious discussions and memorable "would you rather" moments
  • 👫 Excellent ice-breaker, helping guests bond over shared laughter and daring choices
  • 💡 Offers a variety of scenarios, keeping each game fresh and engaging

Cons

  • ⚠️ Content may be too risqué or outrageous for some, limiting its audience
  • 🚫 Not suitable for teenagers or those easily offended
  • ❗️ Enjoyment heavily depends on the group's openness and sense of humor

Should I Buy It?

If your game nights are in need of a lively, adult-oriented boost, and your friends enjoy edgy humor and thought-provoking choices, the Pick Your Poison Card Game: After Dark Edition is a compelling pick. Be mindful of the game's bold content and ensure it matches the preferences of your playgroup for the best experience.

An Entertaining and Hilarious Game for Bold Nights
If you're looking to add some excitement and laughter to your adult game nights, look no further than the Pick Your Poison Card Game: After Dark Edition. This game is an absolute blast and has become a favorite among my friends and me. The concept is simple - players take turns drawing cards that present them with two outrageous scenarios, and they must choose which one they would rather do. These scenarios are bold, daring, and sometimes downright ridiculous, making for endless entertainment and hilarious discussions. What sets the After Dark Edition apart is its daring and risqué content. The questions and challenges delve into the realm of adult humor and push the boundaries, making it perfect for a fun-filled evening with friends who are open-minded and not afraid to get a little wild. The game is incredibly easy to pick up, making it suitable for players of all experience levels. The cards are well-designed, and the instructions are straightforward, ensuring that the focus remains on the hilarity and spontaneity of the game. One of the best aspects of this game is how it brings out everyone's personalities and reveals their hidden preferences and quirks. The revelations and surprising choices often lead to fits of laughter and memorable moments that you'll be talking about long after the game is over. The variety of scenarios keeps the game fresh and exciting, ensuring that every round is unique and keeps the energy high. It's also a fantastic ice-breaker for parties or gatherings, allowing guests to connect and bond over the shared laughter and unforgettable experiences. As with any party game, the enjoyment largely depends on the group you play with, so having a group of friends who are open-minded and enjoy a good laugh is key to fully experiencing the hilarity of Pick Your Poison: After Dark Edition. In conclusion, the Pick Your Poison Card Game: After Dark Edition is a fantastic addition to any adult game night. If you're looking for a game that will break the ice, create lasting memories, and provide countless laughs, this game is an excellent choice. Just be prepared for some wild and outrageous scenarios that will have you questioning your friends' choices and laughing until your sides hurt! ... show more
Reviewed in the United States on July 29, 2023 by Real Deal
Good for large groups and is a refreshing twist on games with similar mechanics.
Review Image by Robin
This game is very similar to cards against humanity (or even apples to apples for the younger crowd) but I think it may even be better for larger groups. We always like to play CAH because there aren't a lot of games that can handle more than 6 people. If someone brings an extra person or 2 to a game night, the group either has to split up or a few people will feel left out. I've been on a hunt for more games that can handle 10+ people or utilize teams because of this. However, with CAH we have noticed if you have a larger group (more than 10) it can become un-manageable because rounds take a while (especially with booze) and people get bored waiting for their turn to be judge. Sometimes I've noticed that people will start to tune out if their cards aren't getting picked or if the some judges aren't picking the funnier cards (humor is relative). This game ads another layer of interaction after the judge reveals the winning card each round - the entire group must answer the horrible question. This extra layer of humor by answering the question kept our group more engaged when people don't have the same humor or ick factors. Also - People who would normally tune out mid rounds were more involved and would start defending their answers. We did a game of 12 last night with this game and everyone was engaged the entire time. Sometimes a hand will happen that is kind of boring (maybe the judge doesn't pick the card that the majority agrees with) and everyone will vote the same way in response. The addition of the double down factor helped keep people excited about winning the lousy round. I'd say the NSFW edition is just that. It's a lot of body parts, sexual taboos, and bodily fluids but both decks are fun. Obviously there aren't as many cards as CAH yet but I think this game is a refreshing new twist. ... show more
Reviewed in the United States on December 17, 2017 by Robin
Fun game
This game is so fun! And it’s a lot dirtier than I expected!
Reviewed in the United States on July 14, 2026 by SierraMartinez
Fun game!
A fun game that definitely gets people talking! The questions sparked a lot of laughs and led to some hilarious conversations. It’s easy to learn and keeps the group engaged without dragging on. I took off one star because some cards felt a little repetitive, but overall it’s a great choice for game nights with friends who don’t mind a little humor and friendly chaos. I’d happily bring it out again. ... show more
Reviewed in the United States on July 9, 2026 by tiatestsit
Fun game with friends
Fun game with friends
Reviewed in the United States on July 19, 2026 by Mathias farnsworth
Fun but beware, there are seriously unfunny cards too
So this game has some really funny moments but whoever wrote the cards should be fired. We had to remove several cards from the game that were not funny, quite harmful, and would have ruined the evening had they been played. Some subjects are too delicate to be made into a drinking game... for instance: the death of someone from an overdose. It’s just not funny, no matter what. So, my recommendation is to preview the cards and remove ones that would upset your guests before the game begins. Otherwise, you might risk deeply upsetting someone. The majority of the cards are awkward, uncomfortable, gross, or some combination of all bad things imaginable. It can be really fun. I would play it again only after sifting through it. ... show more
Reviewed in the United States on January 19, 2019 by Desert Girl
Pick your poison carefully!
Review Image by Kimberly V
Adult card game of “what would you rather do”? Perfect for parties or game night. 3 or more players compete to create hard to beat scenarios using two poison cards. The game will have you giggling and evoke conversation as everyone reveals their “poison” they’ve chosen. It’s a great gift and value for the money. Def a fun game! ... show more
Reviewed in the United States on December 18, 2025 by Kimberly V
I Made It Zoom-Friendly 😁
Review Image by QiyeT LyriQue
So I made this game eFriendly! I was bored and had just bought this game last month bc it looked hilarious, but due to COV19 we haven't had anyone over... but I really wanted to play it! So I posted it on my FB page with a few examples and a few people signed up! We all had a blast and cracked some jokes via Zoom 😁 I will say I did omit some "rules" to make it Zoom-friendly and to make it flow smoothly. If you're interested, read on... - Know exactly how many people are playing; get their emails - Assign a dozen cards to each player (to make it more interesting I purposefully stuck some of "the crazy ones" along with random ones) - Place them together & neatly, comment-side up and take a picture (make sure it's legible) - Set up a Zoom account; notate time/date, link, passcode, etc. - Email players separately with pic of their cards, and include Zoom info. Include any rules you have (what I did was ask players to reply to just me [vs everyone] their answers in the Zoom chat). Based on reactions is how I chose the winner of ea round. - I also reviewed rules on Zoom, just to ensure everyone knew how to play 👍🏼 ... show more
Reviewed in the United States on January 17, 2021 by QiyeT LyriQue
How it works
Checking for best price...