Big Potato Herd Mentality: How Well Do You Know Your Family and Friends? Hilarious Board Game for Ages 10+. 4-20 Players
Condition: New
Buy Now, Pay Later
As low as
$5
/ mo
Learn more
- – 4-month term
- – No impact on credit
- – Instant approval decision
- – Secure and straightforward checkout
Ready to go? Add this product to your cart and select a plan during checkout.
Payment plans are offered through our trusted finance partners Klarna, Affirm, Afterpay, Apple Pay, and PayTomorrow. No-credit-needed leasing options through Acima may also be available at checkout.
Learn more about financing & leasing here.
Selected Option
Free shipping on this product
30-day returns
Learn more
This item is eligible for return within 30 days of receipt
To qualify for a full refund, items must be returned in their original, unused condition. If an item is returned in a used, damaged, or materially different state, you may be granted a partial refund.
To initiate a return, please visit our Returns Center.
View our full returns policy here.
Availability:
Only 8 left in stock, order soon!
Arrives
Thursday, Jan 29
Recently Viewed
Style: Spin Master Games
Features
- WANNA JOIN THE HERD? Flip over a question, grab a pencil and follow the crowd in this family strategy board game.
- WOULD YOU RATHER HAVE ROBOT ARMS OR ROBOT LEGS? Don't know the answer? Try to figure out what everyone else would write! If your answer is in the majority, you win cows.
- LET CATTLE COMMENCE! If your answer is the odd one out, you'll be given the dreaded Pink Cow and you'll have no chance of winning... until you can moo-ve it on to someone else.
- WHATEVER YOU DO, DON'T STAND OUT: This is a Social Deduction game to put all the others out to pasture.
- EASY TO LEARN, QUICK TO PLAY. One of the most udderly amoosing new family board games for 2021. For ages 10+ for between 4-20 players. Ok. We'll stop milking it.
Product Dimensions: 8.13 x 1.75 x 10.63 inches
Item Weight: 1.47 pounds
Item model number: 6059191
Manufacturer recommended age: 10 - 12 years
Release date: July 24, 2025
Manufacturer: Spin Master
Frequently asked questions
If you place your order now, the estimated arrival date for this product is:
Thursday, Jan 29
Yes, absolutely! You may return this product for a full refund within 30 days of receiving it.
To initiate a return, please visit our Returns Center.
View our full returns policy here.
To initiate a return, please visit our Returns Center.
View our full returns policy here.
- Klarna Financing
- Affirm Pay in 4
- Affirm Financing
- Afterpay Financing
- PayTomorrow Financing
- Financing through Apple Pay
Learn more about financing & leasing here.
Similar Products
Top Amazon Reviews
Style: Herd Mentality - Main Game + Bonus Content
This game is easy to learn and great for big groups. It's simple but loads of fun.
Reviewed in the United States on September 29, 2025 by Suspiria
Style: Herd Mentality - Main Game + Bonus Content
Summary: Herd Mentality is a game for 4+ players, ages 10+, from Big Potato Games. (Please see the enclosed pictures.) I highly recommend this game for any group game setting. Each round, a player draws a question, asks the crowd, and everyone (including the reader) writes down an answer. Then, tally up the number of players with the same answer. The players who wrote the most common answer each get a point. The first player to eight points wins. If there is a tie for that round getting to eight points, the winning total goes to nine points and so on until there is a clear winner. One additional rule is important, if you give an answer that is the least popular then you win the "pink cow." You cannot get rid of the pink cow until someone else wins it. You cannot win the game until you get rid of the pink cow. Here are some examples, if four people are playing, and the question is "what is the best flavor of ice cream?" then you could have the following situations: Players A & B say vanilla, and players C & D say chocolate. There are no clear winners and no one gets the pink cow. Players A & B say vanilla, player C says chocolate, and player D says strawberry. Players A & B get one point each. Players A, B & C say vanilla, and player D says chocolate. Players A, B & C get one point, and player D gets the pink cow. On to the Dr Games’ Criteria … GO/NO GO Criterion • Complexity: (GO) This is a relatively easy game. • Balanced: (GO) The game is completely balanced. • Chance: (GO) There is an element of chance in which cards you are drawn and read. • Clarity: (GO) The rules are completely clear. • Reasonable Time: (GO) It generally takes 10-20 minutes. Bonus Criteria • Social: The game is very social, fun, and you learn a lot about the other players. • Unique/Interesting Mechanics: The awarding of the pink cow makes the game much more interesting. • Informed: You potentially learn a lot about the other players. • Rewards Throughout: Yes, once you get a point, it is yours forever.
...
show more
Reviewed in the United States on December 21, 2023 by Reasonable Reviewer Reasonable Reviewer
Style: Spin Master Games
Looking for a game that’ll have your friends shouting, “What were you thinking?!” while simultaneously cackling like hyenas? Herd Mentality is it. We brought this game out at a recent game night, and let’s just say, alliances were formed, friendships were tested, and someone may have mooed so hard they snorted. Gameplay The concept is simple: be a sheep. No, really. The goal is to match your answer with the majority of the herd. If the question is, “What’s the best pizza topping?” and you dare to say anchovies while everyone else writes pepperoni, congratulations—you’re now the proud owner of the Pink Cow card. And trust me, you do not want that card. Highlights Watching someone go on a passionate tirade because they think “pineapple” is the obvious answer to "best pizza topping." Realizing how weirdly specific your friends’ thought processes are. (“What’s the best way to spend a Saturday?” Apparently, not everyone agrees that “Netflix and naps” is the universal truth.) The Pink Cow card becoming a badge of shame that people will fight tooth and hoof to avoid. Pros Quick to learn, so even your most distracted friends will get it. Perfect for all ages—just don’t play with that one edgy cousin who insists on writing inappropriate answers. Endless opportunities to roast each other’s logic—or lack thereof. Cons If you’re a contrarian who loves being different, prepare to lose. A lot. Someone will inevitably get salty when their answer is the only outlier. (“HOW is ‘watermelon’ not the best fruit?!”) Final Thoughts Herd Mentality is the perfect mix of lighthearted fun and chaotic debate. It’s easy to play, impossible to predict, and guarantees laughs every single time. Just remember, in this game, being basic is a virtue. Now excuse me while I try to convince my friends that “crocs” are obviously the best footwear... 🐄
...
show more
Reviewed in the United States on December 29, 2024 by Jim Q
Style: Herd Mentality - Main Game + Bonus Content
Great family game to play with all ages! It was fun to sit around with family to hear what ideas they came up with! It’s a fast paced game and not hard to set up or time consuming. Worth the money for a great game night and definitely has the fun element to keep you thinking as well!
Reviewed in the United States on September 16, 2025 by Bailey Arndt
Style: Moosic and Moovies Edition
Originally, I was a little annoyed at the price (seemed really expensive for what I thought was a smaller box expansion). But, when I got the box in, it made more sense. The box is the same size as the original game. You don't need the other edition to play this version of herd mentality - so, essentially, you could buy this version and play it as a standalone. I LOVE big potato games: they are really so easy that just about anyone can play and catch on quick! This game hits the table often along with Chameleon and Sounds Fishy. For MOOOOOOSIC and MOOOOOOVIES, the topics are pretty fun and everything seems pretty well made. No complaints. The speed of play is the same as the regular game. It's really an easy game (you could play with kids, no problem, if they can write). The prompts are varied. My critical feedback would be two things: 1) Games like this usually have a fun twist to make it different from the original. Sure, the golden cow is different visually; but, there's no difference in game play. Same game, different color scheme (basically). 2) Have an option to buy new cards to expand the original game. Overall, this isn't a must have if you own the original version - but it's a good game overall and I would recommend it if you were more into the theme of this specific version.
...
show more
Reviewed in the United States on August 21, 2024 by Emma
Style: Herd Mentality - Main Game + Bonus Content
Bought for teen daughter and friends but the family wound up playing too. Fun questions, family friendly, easy for any age.
Reviewed in the United States on October 29, 2025 by Goaliegirl