Search  for anything...
High Cheese

High Cheese Baseball Walk Off Mystery Pack - 2 Cards, 1 PSA Graded & 1 Autograph/Relic Ungraded

  • Based on 183 reviews
Condition: New
Checking for the best price...
$39.99 Why this price?
Save $5.00 was $44.99

Buy Now, Pay Later

As low as $9 / mo
  • – 4-month term
  • – No impact on credit to apply
  • – Instant approval decision
  • – Secure and straightforward checkout

Ready to go? Add this product to your cart and select a plan during checkout.

Payment plans are offered through our trusted finance partners Klarna, Affirm, Afterpay, Apple Pay, and PayTomorrow. No-credit-needed leasing options through Acima may also be available at checkout.

Learn more about financing & leasing here.

Free shipping on this product

FREE 30-day refund/replacement

To qualify for a full refund, items must be returned in their original, unused condition. If an item is returned in a used, damaged, or materially different state, you may be granted a partial refund.

To initiate a return, please visit our Returns Center.

View our full returns policy here.

Availability: In Stock.
Fulfilled by Amazon
Arrives Friday, Apr 17
Order within 14 hours and 52 minutes
Available payment plans shown during checkout
Protection Plan Protect Your Purchase
Checking for protection plans...

Recently Viewed

Features

  • Guaranteed Autograph or Relic: Each pack contains 1 PSA card and 1 autographed or relic card.
  • Mystery Pack: The contents are a surprise, adding excitement to the unboxing experience.
  • Baseball Card Collectibles: Featuring cards from the popular High Cheese baseball card brand.
  • 2 Card Pack: Each pack contains 2 cards, providing value for collectors.

Description

Elevate your baseball card collection with the High Cheese Baseball Card Walk Off Mystery Pack! This exhilarating 2-card pack guarantees one PSA-graded card and one autographed or relic card, adding an extra layer of excitement and value to your collection. With each pack, you'll experience the thrill of unveiling a piece of baseball history, whether it's a coveted autograph from a legendary player or a game-used relic that transports you to iconic moments on the diamond. Immerse yourself in the nostalgia and passion of America's favorite pastime with this must-have pack for any serious collector. Embrace the mystery and let the anticipation build as you unravel the surprises within, one unforgettable card at a time.

Theme: Autograph, Baseball, Sport


Is Autographed: Yes


Sub Brand: High Cheese Baseball


Included Components: Card


Age Range (Description): Adult


Year: 2024


Size: 4 inches by 7 inches by 0.1 inches


Material: Paper


Product Dimensions: 7"L x 4"W


Authenticity By: PSA


Item Weight: 1.76 ounces


Item model number: WO


Manufacturer recommended age: 3 years and up


Manufacturer: High Cheese Baseball


Frequently asked questions

If you place your order now, the estimated arrival date for this product is: Friday, Apr 17

Yes, absolutely! You may return this product for a full refund within 30 days of receiving it.

To initiate a return, please visit our Returns Center.

View our full returns policy here.

  • Klarna Financing
  • Affirm Pay in 4
  • Affirm Financing
  • Afterpay Financing
  • PayTomorrow Financing
  • Financing through Apple Pay
Leasing options through Acima may also be available during checkout.

Learn more about financing & leasing here.

Similar Products

Top Amazon Reviews

    • 0% chance of positive return.
Knowing it's a gamble and being ok with that, I still was not satisfied BECAUSE... The 2 cards that arrived were: 1 autographed card from a player who retired 6 years ago and was never a star, mediocre at best. 1 Graded 10! Autographed card from a player who was DFA 5 years ago, never returned to the majors, and is not currently on ANY TEAM. 2 cards that for years now is known have no chance of going UP in value, therefore, why are they still in the pool? Another time, I received a Wander Franco card well AFTER the arrest, charge, and after the conviction. It's not even a gamble if there is 0% chance of appreciation. It's taking customers' money with no possibility of a positive return. ... show more
Reviewed in the United States on January 23, 2026 by Christian quickle
    • Very good seller really great cards!!
It’s a really great product very happy with the price and packaging and It was well worth the money thank you very much Thank you so much I really got hooked up!!
Reviewed in the United States on February 4, 2026 by Thomas L.
    • Terrible Value. Graded Base Card Scam
Absolutely terrible. Literally worthless cards. Wasn’t expecting anything outstanding, or even worth the money, but a PSA 8 graded Base Card from Allen and Ginter is pretty ridiculous. Do not recommend in any way.
Reviewed in the United States on January 28, 2026 by Daniel Bender
    • Fair hit
I now forgot what card I got in this pack because I’m writing this review late and I’m just guessing it wasn’t a Mickey Mantle or anything? Because then I would definitely remember!! 🤣
Reviewed in the United States on February 12, 2026 by Dave
    • Not a whole lot of value for the price.
I think this is a pretty good idea. It is fun and there is an element of chance. It is always nice to add a graded card to a collection. However, what I received was a player card that is from 2020 and the player is not even in the MLB anymore. They are now playing in the Mexican league. The autograph card I received is nice, not sure the player is still active, but if that is the case, never heard of them either. I think to make this worth it, it would be nice to see current or well known retired players. I know you need to make money and I would not expect every package to be a "hit", but at best these two cards are worth $5. This feels like you are purging old cards that maybe once had potential and the players never materialized. Now, I am stuck with them. But, kind of a fun idea, just not really worth it to do often or really more than one more time just to see what I get. I received a graded Mint 9 Aristedes Aquino from 2020 and a Sam Hentges rookie auto on Bowman Chrome. ... show more
Reviewed in the United States on May 21, 2025 by Rejean Y. Plante
    • Poor Condition, Crappy cards given
Ungraded card was in poor condition, worth nothing.
Reviewed in the United States on July 29, 2025 by Nolan Spangler
    • It’s ok fun .but I don’t see a return on your investment
Review Image by Giovanni Perez Giovanni Perez
Pretty cool fun card was psa graded 9 . Still could of just probably buy the same card and saved for a hobby or fun definitely if your trying to make a investment not high odds
Reviewed in the United States on January 22, 2026 by Giovanni Perez Giovanni Perez
    • DON’T
Not worth the money, graded base card and it was only a PSA 8, Specialty card was a no name. I understand it’s a mystery pack but a for a total value of $11 in cards it’s simply not worth it.
Reviewed in the United States on November 18, 2025 by Amazon Customer

Can't find a product?

Find it on Amazon first, then paste the link below.
Checking for best price...